How to Fix Broken Internal Links Hurting Your Rankings

Broken internal links are one of those small website issues that can quietly cause a lot of trouble. You might not see them at first, but when they pile up, they start to affect how well your site performs. When users click on a link expecting to land on a helpful page and instead hit an error, it’s frustrating. If search engines keep finding these broken links, they start to lower your site’s ranking because your site seems less reliable. Fixing them isn’t just a technical task — it’s about keeping the user experience smooth and your website trusted by search engines.

For businesses in Toronto, staying visible online is more important than ever. When local users search for services or products, it helps to have a strong online presence backed by solid site structure. SEO consultants in Toronto often run into sites loaded with long-forgotten pages or mistyped URLs that quietly drag rankings down. The good news is these problems can be fixed with a little attention and consistent upkeep. Taking care of your broken links not only helps your users but plays a big role in improving your site’s visibility across the Greater Toronto Area and beyond.

Identifying Broken Links

The first step in fixing broken links is finding them. It sounds easy, but it can be tricky if you don’t know where to look. Some broken links show up because pages have been moved, renamed, or deleted without updating the links that lead to them. Others break due to old redirects that no longer work. Whatever the reason, catching them early can save your website and your rankings from slipping.

Here are a few simple ways Toronto businesses can spot broken internal links:

  1. Use tools like Screaming Frog or Ahrefs. These scan your site and list out all pages with errors, including broken links.
  2. Set up Google Search Console. It shows crawl errors and alerts you to any issues Google finds while indexing your site.
  3. Browse through your website manually once in a while, especially key landing pages and blog posts. Click through links to double-check they still work.
  4. Keep an updated sitemap and use it as a checklist. Compare what’s live on your site right now against the links in the sitemap.
  5. Check your CMS, if you use one, for built-in reports or extensions that point out broken links.

Let’s say you run a small hair studio in Toronto. You recently updated your service menu page and removed older pricing information but forgot to update the internal links on your booking and blog pages. As a result, visitors get sent to a 404 error page. Even if this only happens once or twice, that can be enough to shake trust and hurt how your site shows up in search.

The tools and habits listed above take a bit of time, but they can help save future headaches. Most of all, they give you some control over how your website performs and how visitors feel when they navigate it. Keeping your site easy to explore makes both search engines and potential clients happier.

The Impact Of Broken Links On SEO

Broken internal links are more than just an inconvenience for people visiting your site. They also make your website harder for search engines to understand and trust. When a search engine like Google finds too many broken links, it may see your site as poorly maintained. That can pull your rankings down and make it harder for people to find your business online.

For small businesses in Toronto who rely on local visibility, this isn’t the kind of problem you want creeping up unnoticed. If someone lands on your site from a local search and clicks on a broken link, that experience sticks. It can make your business seem outdated or careless, even if the issue was just a forgotten page from six months ago. And once someone clicks away, they may not come back.

Search engines want users to have a good experience, and broken links suggest the opposite. Pages that lead nowhere signal that parts of your site are falling apart. Even one or two broken paths can affect crawling. This is how search engines discover and categorise your pages. When paths are broken, some pages don’t get indexed, which means they won’t show up in search results at all.

Say you’re a local clothing shop in Toronto with an old blog that used to get a lot of traffic. Maybe you moved a couple of featured product pages, but you didn’t update the links in your older posts that talk about those items. Every time someone clicks one of those links, they get nothing. That traffic drops. Your bounce rate jumps. Your blog becomes less useful to both readers and search engines. This is how a small mistake can make a big difference.

Fixing Broken Internal Links: What To Do

Once you’ve tracked the broken links, it’s time to fix them. The goal here isn’t just patching pages but creating a cleaner, smoother experience across your site. That means being a bit patient and running through things link by link to make sure you’re solving the root issues.

  1. Here’s a list of simple ways to approach repairing broken internal links:
  2. Update the link destination: If the page still exists but under a new URL, update the link to point to the correct one.
  3. Remove the link: If the page no longer exists and there isn’t a relevant replacement, it’s better to remove the link than to leave it broken.
  4. Replace with relevant content: Link to a similar or related page that would still be helpful to the user.
  5. Use 301 redirects: If many sources across your site point to a page that you’ve moved or removed, set up proper 301 redirects so visitors and search engines get sent to the right place automatically.
  6. Check for typos: Sometimes the URL works fine, but there’s a typo in the hyperlink that leads to an error. These are easy to overlook and simple to fix.

Consistency is key here. The longer broken links stay on your site, the more they can affect rankings and user flow. Try to deal with them promptly once found. Fix a few at a time if your list is long. What matters most is regular clean-up and staying on top of changes when you add or remove pages.

Preventing Future Link Breaks

Fixing broken links is one thing. Keeping them from piling up again is another. The best way to keep your site in shape long-term is by putting a few habits in place. This doesn’t need to take a ton of time. A little bit of ongoing effort goes further than a big clean-up every few years.

To keep your internal links healthy:

  1. Do regular audits: Set a reminder to check your site for broken links every few months.
  2. Keep a link log: If you create a new page or delete one, jot it down. That log makes it easier to track where changes happened.
  3. Use a content checklist: Before publishing a new post or page, check all internal links you added. Are they working? Are they updated?
  4. Try link-checking plugins if your site supports them. Some platforms offer automated alerts when a link breaks.
  5. Coordinate across your team: If you have several people managing content, make sure updates get shared. Communication helps keep things consistent.

These simple tips help reduce the chance of errors slipping through. If you’re running a business in Toronto and working with local pages, make sure changes to location-specific content get updated across the site too. For example, if you opened a new storefront and refreshed your service page, any links pointing to your old store’s location should reflect that.

Making It Easier for People to Stay on Your Site

Even small internal link issues can affect how people perceive your business online. It’s not just about fixing one link. It’s about making sure your entire site feels professional and trustworthy from the first click to the last. When someone visits a page and everything loads properly and connects as expected, it shows your business is active and pays attention to detail.

For Toronto businesses trying to stay visible in a busy market, strong internal site structure can offer a helpful edge. Good link hygiene tells both people and search engines that your website is current, clear, and worth ranking higher. It keeps your site easy to explore, improves how your content is found, and gives your visitors more reasons to stick around.

If you’re working with SEO consultants in Toronto, cleaning up internal links is often one of the first fixes they recommend, and with good reason. It’s one of those background tasks that quietly but steadily supports everything else you’re doing to grow your online visibility. When your links work, your site works better. Simple as that.

To keep your website running smoothly and ranking well, it helps to get guidance from SEO consultants in Toronto. At Laughton Creatves, we focus on making your site easier to navigate and more inviting for users, which keeps your audience engaged and your site performing the way it should. Let’s work together to support your website’s growth with smart fixes that make a lasting impact.